Sola Scriptura, Part 10

Subjective Christianity promotes unity by accepting all faith professions, emphasizing love over doctrine. It critiques Sola Scriptura, advocating personal spiritual guidance.
Published: July 28, 2015
← Back to HOTM Evangelicalism

Episode Description:

Subjective Christianity is an inclusive approach to faith in Jesus Christ that emphasizes unity by accepting all professions of faith and allowing individuals the freedom to pursue Christ according to the guidance of the Holy Spirit, regardless of doctrinal or dogmatic differences. Shawn McCraney highlights 1 Corinthians passages to support this concept, advocating for a faith that transcends divisions like those over doctrines such as eternal punishment, sola scriptura, and the Trinity, to unite believers as followers of Christ.

Paul emphasizes the importance of true spiritual understanding and love in the Christian journey, highlighting in 1st Corinthians that merely adhering to doctrine or knowledge without charity is meaningless, and suggests that love and unity should prevail within the community of believers, as the essence of faith lies not in the written law but in spiritual power. Furthermore, Paul warns against the dangers of legalism and division arising from strict adherence to scripture alone, suggesting that the strength of sin is rooted in the law, and instead, advocates for peace and the life-giving spirit beyond written doctrine, as demonstrated by the numerous Christian denominations worldwide.

Shawn argues against the concept of Sola Scriptura, highlighting that relying solely on scripture for religious authority leads to divisions and contradicts the Reformation's goal of making the Bible accessible to the masses. By focusing on figures like Wycliffe, Erasmus, and Luther, Shawn emphasizes that differing interpretations and the institutional control by religious leaders have historically divided believers, despite scripture's availability aiming to empower personal understanding through spiritual engagement.

John Wycliffe advocated for individual interpretation of the Bible, challenging the Catholic Church by emphasizing personal spiritual responsibility over clerical authority and expressing strong opposition to monasticism, temporal church involvement, and church hierarchy. He pioneered the translation of the Bible into English vernacular, paving the way for the Reformation, and despite severe persecution, his ideas on deconstructing institutional Christianity gained considerable influence, culminating in movements like the Peasants' Revolt.

Shawn emphasizes the centrality of "Sola Scriptura," originally championed by Wycliffe, highlighting the importance of personal interpretation of scripture while critiquing figures like Martin Luther for imposing their interpretations, which led to religious authority and division. He proposes that true unity comes from faith in Jesus, allowing the Holy Spirit to guide individuals, and prioritizing love over doctrinal disputes, suggesting that religious leaders should humbly acknowledge the limits of their understanding.

Shawn emphasizes understanding the concept of God in Christianity beyond the traditional doctrine of the Trinity, highlighting how scriptural references and interpretations can present alternate perspectives. He encourages exploring biblical passages and external resources to gain a deeper, personal understanding of the nature of God and how believers relate to Him in prayer and worship.