Doctrine Makes the Man – Introduction

Shawn critiques Mormonism, emphasizing truth-seeking over myth defense, contrasts LDS and biblical Christianity on salvation, and highlights doctrinal differences and youth ministry.
Published: July 31, 2013
← Back to HOTM Evangelicalism

Episode Description:

Shawn McCraney discusses a large reunion of Joseph Smith's descendants that aims to set a world record and critiques organizations like FAIR as being focused on defending myths instead of seeking truth, contrasting them with groups like Sunstone that encourage open inquiry into Mormonism. He emphasizes the importance of pursuing knowledge and truth, particularly regarding Jesus, despite modern intellectuals often perceiving faith as inconclusive.

Feelings can deceive us into making choices contrary to God's commandments, as seen in Eve's sensory-driven decision in Eden, but His law exists outside our emotional responses and guides us towards righteousness. Biblical Christianity teaches that salvation is based on faith in Jesus Christ, contrasting with the LDS view, which involves grace after personal merit through adherence to laws and ordinances.

Shawn emphasizes that true freedom and salvation come through faith in Jesus Christ and His redemptive work, encouraging individuals to seek truth personally rather than relying on religious institutions, specifically critiquing Mormonism for overpromising. He compares organized Christianity and Mormonism, highlighting that while lifestyle and practices may appear similar, foundational theological beliefs significantly differ and drive each religion's teachings and operations.

Church leadership structures in both Christian and Mormon communities share similarities in governance, social activities, love for family, and congregational challenges, but they diverge significantly on topics such as spiritual gifts, cultural practices, theological views on salvation, and beliefs about God and Christ. While both groups strive to love their congregations and face similar issues of community management, major doctrinal differences separate biblical Christianity from Mormon doctrines, which will be further explored in the next session.

Shawn critiques the evangelical church's approach to youth ministry, highlighting the contrast with Mormon practices, where young men are ordained at an early age and committed to consistent mission work, resulting in fewer former adherents leaving the faith. He also addresses the rise in the palatability of Mormonism through media figures like Glenn Beck, stressing the potential danger in portraying it as mainstream despite differing from orthodox Christian beliefs.

Shawn emphasizes that members of the body of Christ have the duty to challenge heretical teachings that threaten the integrity of the faith, using the example of Mormonism as a point of discussion. He also highlights the importance of fostering inclusive and open dialogues within Christian communities, urging them to be discerning yet compassionate when engaging with belief systems, so that they don’t alienate seekers or inadvertently strengthen contrary beliefs.

Shawn emphasizes the importance of discerning truth from false doctrine and challenges individuals to scrutinize religious beliefs critically, particularly focusing on inconsistencies within Mormonism and broader Christian contexts. He encourages exploring genuine truths, transcending comforting lies, and fostering open dialogues about religious practices while addressing misconceptions through informed discussions and personal experiences.

Attending the service left me feeling uneasy due to the lack of emphasis on faith and the Lord, and despite participating in various activities, the overall experience felt like a mind-twist, lacking joy and enthusiasm. Thanks to your teachings, I now feel at ease and have a knowledge advantage that helped me navigate the unfamiliar concepts discussed, such as church history and "the pride cycle," despite the unsettling atmosphere.

Shawn's teaching emphasizes the need for people, especially Mormons, to incorporate Jesus into their lives as a missing element, as shared by Charles who expressed gratitude for Shawn's influence and sought prayers for spiritual guidance. Additionally, recent changes in the dress standards for LDS missionaries, such as lighter suits and the non-requirement of suit coats in certain conditions, reflect the Church's effort to adapt to evolving perceptions and make its missionary work more accessible and relatable.