Adam and Eve

Shawn McCraney critiques Mormon views on Adam and Eve, contrasting them with biblical teachings. He emphasizes their disobedience led to humanity's fall, challenging LDS doctrines.
Published: January 5, 2010
← Back to HOTM Mormonism

Episode Description:

Shawn McCraney discusses the biblical account of Adam and Eve, emphasizing that God created Adam from the dust and breathed life into him, while Eve was made from Adam's rib, to exist together in a state described as heavenly, free from suffering. He contrasts this biblical teaching with Mormon doctrines, highlighting the original state of humanity in the Garden of Eden where they could choose to love and honor God without coercion, or alternatively, pursue their path based on personal ideas.

In Shawn's teaching, Adam and Eve, despite being given everything by God, chose to disobey because they were tempted by the serpent, resulting in humanity's fall from paradise and an existence marked by pain and separation from God. Their actions reflect the tension between following God's commands for ultimate blessings and succumbing to worldly temptations, leading to adverse consequences like shame and death.

Shawn critiques Mormon beliefs about Adam and Eve, highlighting how they deviate from traditional Christian teachings by asserting that Adam was originally the archangel Michael and played a significant role in creation, contrary to biblical accounts. He also points out that Mormonism attributes the title "Ancient of Days" to Adam and believes that Adam and Eve were given contradictory commandments, a concept Shawn argues undermines the biblical narrative and portrays God as deceitful.

Mormon doctrine asserts that Old Testament prophets and figures like Adam and Eve were fully aware of the LDS plan of salvation from the beginning, which contradicts biblical teachings of progressive revelation as stated in Romans 16 and Ephesians. According to LDS beliefs, Adam and Eve’s “transgressions” were necessary steps for mankind’s existence and joy, and their actions were not considered sin but a required transgression to fulfill God’s plan—this contrasts with Christian teachings on sin and redemption, illustrating significant theological divergence and complexity.

The teaching by Shawn asserts that the LDS (Latter-day Saints) view of Adam and Eve's actions as commendable is a contradiction to biblical teachings, which clearly define their actions as disobedience and origin of sin according to scripture. The LDS theology of Adam and Eve being praised for their choices is challenged by emphasizing that God's intention was never to endorse sin and suffering, hence questioning the motives behind Satan's temptation if their actions were supposedly necessary for God's plan.

Shawn emphasizes the importance of actively listening and speaking with intention to cultivate meaningful communication, encouraging individuals to seek understanding and align their words with their values and purpose. He advises that expressing oneself thoughtfully and authentically can lead to deeper connections and a more positive impact in personal and professional relationships.