Book of Mormon, Part 6

Shawn McCraney critiques LDS history portrayal, emphasizes devotion to Jesus over church, questions Book of Mormon's authenticity, and plans to explore witness credibility.
Published: May 8, 2007
← Back to HOTM Mormonism

Episode Description:

Shawn McCraney critiques the PBS program “The Mormons” for its partial admissions about controversial aspects of LDS history, comparing it to a deception tactic where partial truth is used to gain acceptance and conceal greater issues, rather than fully disclosing troubling details about the Mormon faith. He emphasizes the utmost importance of prioritizing devotion to Jesus Christ above familial and societal ties, stating that true allegiance to Him enhances one’s capacity to love others, regardless of differing priorities or values.

In a critical examination of religious identity, the study involving LDS and Christian youth revealed that LDS youth primarily identified with "Church" over Jesus, contrasting with Christian peers who highlighted Jesus, God, or The Lord, illustrating a significant difference between prioritizing religious institutions and cultivating a personal relationship with divinity. This analysis segues into questioning the Book of Mormon's authenticity by highlighting apparent anachronisms and similarities to nearby geographical places, suggesting possible influences from contemporary sources like the 1823 book "View of the Hebrews," attributed to Pastor Ethan Smith, whose work predated and possibly influenced Joseph Smith and Oliver Cowdery.

Shawn's teaching suggests that the Book of Mormon, traditionally believed to be a translation of an ancient record, may actually have been compiled by Joseph Smith using information from existing texts, casting doubt on its origins and authenticity. This stance challenges the traditional narratives upheld by the LDS Church, and Shawn plans to further explore related topics, including the credibility of the witnesses to the golden plates.